Skip to content
  • Free UK delivery over £50
  • Click & Collect in Haverhill
  • Independent tackle shop since day one

Dead Baits for Pike: Which to Use, How to Rig Them and When

October 20, 2026 claytonstackle@gmail.com
Pike fishing rods set up on a misty winter gravel pit at dawn

The best dead baits for pike are oily sea fish, smelt, mackerel, sardine, herring and lamprey, along with coarse fish such as roach. Fish them on a wire trace of at least 28lb, either float-legered or straight on the bottom, from October through to March. That one paragraph is most of what you need. The rest of this guide is the detail that turns a blank into a twenty.

Why dead baits work so well in winter

Pike are ambush predators, but they’re also scavengers. Once the water cools they burn less energy chasing lures and spend more time picking off easy meals from the bottom. A dead bait lying in the silt, leaking scent, is exactly that. It asks nothing of the fish. In water below about 8 degrees a static dead bait will usually out-fish a lure, and it fishes for you while you keep your hands in your pockets.

Which dead baits should you buy?

There’s no single magic bait, but some have earned their reputation.

Smelt smell faintly of cucumber, stay on the hooks well and pike adore them. Mackerel are tough, cheap and extremely oily. A half mackerel, cut diagonally so the body leaks, is probably the most reliable winter bait there is. Sardines are softer and want gentle casting, but they put out more scent than almost anything else. Lamprey leak blood into the water and have a cult following on hard-fished pits. Herring sit somewhere between mackerel and sardine. And don’t ignore coarse deads, a roach or small skimmer is what pike eat every day of their lives.

If we could only take two to the bank, it would be half a mackerel on one rod and a smelt on the other. Browse what’s in our freezer in the dead baits range.

How to rig a dead bait

One rule before anything else: always use a wire trace. No exceptions, no “the fluoro will be fine”. A pike’s teeth will go through mono and braid alike, and a bitten-off trace usually means a dead pike. Ready-made traces of 28lb wire with two semi-barbless size 6 or 8 trebles are cheap and they work. You’ll find them with the rest of our predator end tackle.

Hook the bait with the top treble in the root of the pectoral fin and the lower treble in the flank. Then pick a presentation:

Float-legered is the classic. A sliding pike float up the line, a weight to pin the bait down, and the float telling you the moment anything picks it up. It’s visual, it’s effective, and on a cold morning watching that float is half the fun.

Straight legering with a drop-off indicator at the rod end is better in wind or at long range. Less to watch, nothing to drift.

Strike early, every time

This matters more than bait choice. When a pike takes, don’t give it time to “turn the bait”. That old advice deep-hooks fish. Wind down and strike as soon as you’re sure the run is a run. You’ll land virtually every fish hooked neatly in the scissors, and the pike swims off none the worse.

Carry long forceps, side cutters and a proper unhooking mat. Pike look fearsome and are actually the most fragile fish in the lake. Our predator tools and fish care kit cover all of it. If you’re starting from scratch, our predator fishing for beginners guide walks through the full setup.

When and where

October to March is prime time, and the first two hours of daylight are worth the next six put together. Look for drop-offs, dying weedbeds, and anywhere prey fish shoal up for winter. If nothing happens in 45 minutes, twitch the bait a few feet or recast to a new spot. A moved bait very often gets picked up within minutes.

FAQs

Do I really need a wire trace for dead baiting?

Yes, always. At least 28lb wire, around 45cm long. Pike bite through mono and fluorocarbon, and a trace left in a fish is usually fatal for it.

Are sea baits or coarse baits better for pike?

Both catch. Sea baits like mackerel and smelt are oilier and put more scent in the water. Coarse baits like roach look natural on pressured waters. Take a mix until the lake tells you its preference.

How long should I let a run develop?

Don’t. Wind down and strike as soon as the run is confirmed. Waiting deep-hooks pike and does them real harm.

What size dead bait is best?

In winter, modest. A whole smelt or half a mackerel is plenty. A smaller bait gets picked up by more fish and is easier to strike cleanly.

Stocking up for a session? Grab your dead baits and traces online, or pop into the shop at 4 Queen Street, Haverhill and we’ll put a winter piking kit together with you. Call us on 01440 810120 if you want to check what’s in the freezer first.

Fast UK DeliveryNext-day options available
Price Match PromiseFound it cheaper? Tell us
Secure CheckoutKlarna & all major cards
Expert SupportAnglers who know their kit

Join the Claytons mailing list

Be first to hear about new stock, offers and in-store events.